AT THE WEDDING
 
 

Jan 20 - Feb 14, 2026

Written By: Bryna Turner

Shows: Tuesdays-Saturdays at 7:30pm

 

Patrons will be cordially invited to a Northern California wedding and meet Carlo, an agent of comedic chaos, as she attempts to make it through the night without drinking too much, talking too much, or trying to win back the bride.

Cast: Jess Polak, Martha Hooten-Hattingh, Jody Orrigo, Rita Troxel, Susannah Wells, Jessica Miano Kruel, Jack McDonald
Director: Joy Hawkins


RED BARN CELEBRATES WITH THE HEARTFELT AND HILARIOUS “AT THE WEDDING”

group of men and women standing together in a group in front of a red building

Cast of Red Barn’s Production AT THE WEDDING

Ah, weddings. Those wonderful celebrations of love and the commitment of two hearts to the sharing of a life together. We expect an evening of joy, laughter, too much good food and drink, and endless toasts to the happy couple.

And then there is the somewhat sideways reception for the nuptials depicted in Bryna Turner’s heartfelt and hilarious “At The Wedding,” the next mainstage presentation in the Red Barn Theatre’s 46th season. Running January  20 through February 14 at their 319 Duval Street facility, it is an invitation that you surely won’t want to miss.

It’s not that Turner’s very funny play doesn’t have all the trappings of a typical joy-filled wedding. They’re in there somewhere. But she has reimagined the classic wedding-genre story by lampooning the tropes of such stories and adding just enough off-the-wall spice to elevate the play into the rare air of great comedy that manages to deliver a poignant message.

The story centers around a gregarious wiseacre named Carlo who has crashed the wedding of her ex-girlfriend, Eva, a vivacious young woman that has left their gay relationship to marry a straight man. Carlo has several goals in attending: not to get drunk, not to make little kids cry, and to try to win back Eva. The play is fast-paced, sharp, funny, and emotional, blending its humor with poignant reflections on love, loneliness, and heartbreak.

Along the way, we meet a cornucopia of great characters: Carly, the bridesmaid and “frenemy” of Carlo; Eli, a  high school English teacher who thinks all of life can be explained in The Rime of the Ancient Mariner; Leigh, an alluring guest who flirts with Carlo and tries to get her to ditch the wedding with her; Victor, a very charming waiter; and Maria, the classic mother of the bride. The brilliance of Turner’s play is how she uses the interactions of these characters to examine how societal institutions often fail to accommodate diverse human experiences. And she does it while making us laugh out loud.

The play features the talents of Jess Polak, Martha Hooten-Hattingh, Jody Orrigo, Rita Troxel, Susannah Wells, Jessica Miano-Kruel, and Jack McDonald. It is directed by Joy Hawkins.

“I loved the play instantly,” said director Hawkins, also the Red Barn’s artistic director. “She’s a total fresh voice. The play has a nuance and poignancy, and a very special sweetness. It’s very today. We get to take this journey with this woman who is so adorably lost, and we get a great romantic look at life and how hard it can be sometimes. It’s simply an adorable play.”

DC Theatre Arts called the show “…wickedly funny…with plot twists and laugh-a-minute dialogue…”. TheatreMania called it “…brutally hilarious…”. The New York Times says, “…spritely smart…so fresh…so funny…”.

Tickets for “At The Wedding” can be purchased at redbarntheatre.com or 305-296-9911. Curtains for all shows are at 7:30 pm. Be aware that there is no parking at the Red Barn Theatre.

Susannah Wells
AND THE WORLD GOES ROUND
 
 

Feb 24 - Mar 21, 2026

The Songs of John Kander & Fred Ebb

Shows: Tuesdays-Saturdays at 7:30pm

 

An intimate musical revue celebrating the extraordinary work of the composer and lyricist of (among others) “Chicago,” “Cabaret,” “Kiss of the Spider Woman,” and the movie scores for “Funny Lady” and “New York, New York.”

“Wonderfully rich, sophisticated and satisfying “ — BroadwayWorld

Cast: Lauren Thompson, Jeremy Zoma, Claire Caplan, Arthur Crocker
Directors: Joy Hawkins and Lauren Thompson
Musical Direction: Michael Fauss


RED BARN BRINGS THE BRILLIANCE OF BROADWAY’S KANDER AND EBB TO THEIR STAGE

Every musical theater lover knows there’s a special magic woven into every Broadway musical, an alchemy of melodies and lyrics that worm their way into the mind and memory, where they take up residence forever.

Key West’s Red Barn Theatre will present an evening of the best of these alchemic confections by two of Broadway’s most celebrated musical wizards in “And The World Goes Round – The Music of Kander and Ebb.” The show runs February 24 through March 21. All curtains are at 7:30 pm.

Composer John Kander and lyricist Fred Ebb were one of Broadway’s most creative, versatile, and dynamic musical theater writing teams. Over their partnership of 40 years, they created over 15 of Broadway’s greatest classics, including “Cabaret,” “Chicago,” “Kiss of the Spider Woman,” “Woman of the Year,” “Zorba,” and “New York, New York,” among many others. Many of their shows found their way onto the silver screen as well.

“And The World Goes Round” is a unique evening of the duo’s work – a clever collage of love songs, torch songs, and witty comic numbers cherry-picked from their top shows. But while it is a musical revue, the show – originally conceived by director Scott Ellis, choreographer Susan Stroman, and librettist David Thompson –is something far more unique. It accomplishes the feat of expressing the lives and emotions of characters through the music alone, without the need for a story line or character dialogue. The songs serve as a lens into the lives of the characters on stage, exploring love, heartbreak, hope, and the resilience of the human spirit, all through Kander and Ebb’s unique blend of wit and emotion.

The show stars four great Key West voices -- Lauren Thompson, Claire Caplan, Arthur Crocker, and Jeremy Zoma. A real extra plus for this show is having musical direction by New York’s Michael Fauss, a Broadway orchestrator and musical director for such shows as “Brigadoon,” and “Oliver!”. The show will be co-directed by Red Barn artistic director Joy Hawkins and Lauren Thompson, who also handles the bulk of the choreography.

“I love that we get to celebrate these men who are icons of Broadway,” said Hawkins. “They wrote such celebrated Broadway musicals, with intricate harmonies and fancy footwork. This is a terrific night of music, and a celebration of these men who served musical theatre so brilliantly. This will be one of our best musical offerings ever.”

The show ran for over a year in New York, garnering Drama Desk and Lucille Lortel awards for Outstanding Musical Revue. Broadway World called it “…stylish, sophisticated, and thoroughly satisfying…”. MD Theatre Guide said it is “…one of the most satisfying and enjoyable musical evenings I’ve ever experienced…”. The Marriott Theatre Review said it is “…an emotional thrill ride of amazing voices…”.

Tickets can be purchased at redbarntheatre.com or by calling the box office at 305-296-9911. The show is sponsored in part by Duval Street Media, the Florida Keys Council of the Arts, and the Monroe Country Tourist Development Council.

Susannah Wells
A ROCK SAILS BY

Thrifty Thursday Special for A ROCK SAILS BY - buy two tickets for just $90 + fees by using the Discount Code: "THRIFTYTHURSDAY”

 
 

Mar 31 - Apr 25, 2026

Written by: Sean Grennan

Shows: Tuesdays-Saturdays at 7:30pm

 

When a UFO is sighted heading towards Earth, astrophysicist Dr. Lynn Cummings grants an interview to a journalist who has misquoted her. She invites him to view with her the object as it comes closest to Earth. There is no telling what she will discover beyond the stars.

“A soul searching delight” — Coral Gables Magazine 

“A thought-provoking story filled with wit, humor and emotion “ — BroadwayWorld

Cast: George DeBraud, Susannah Wells, Jody Orrigo, Lauren Thompson, Fritzie Estimond, and Glenda Donovan
Director: Joy Hawkins


Susannah Wells